The Phantom of the Opera (September 9th, 2016)

The Phantom of the Opera

September 9th, 2016

I promised a lot of people a review of Ben, and others a review of Harriet once I saw her, so…. Killing two birds with one stone here! Because last time I saw Ben, I had to write an essay on him, and didn’t feel like doing another review on top of that. In this case though, the show and performances were so incredible that I’m sat writing this all down at 2am so I won’t forget it. I've done enough seat and venue reviews for this show, so I'm just launching right into the review.

I have to start with Harriet because… well… she’s Harriet. My most seen Christine, and one of my special favourites for a myriad of reasons. I was so, so delighted when she announced she was coming back, and by sheer luck (don’t ask!) managed to make it to a show in her first week back.

When you see Harriet as Christine, you’re always guaranteed a good show. I always think of her as the ‘cleanest’ Christine (like how a gymnast can have a ‘clean’ – i.e. mistake-free – routine; that’s where I get it from anyway). So I knew walking in she was going to be good, because she always is. After a year off, though, you expect a few bumps and inconsistencies. But I was completely and utterly blown away (and reduced to tears within minutes) by how ridiculously brilliant she’s become. Her acting is just phenomenal. From the moment she stepped onstage; she just was Christine (also her dancing has improved and her arabesques look beautiful). When she was sitting with Meg on the floor in Hannibal, and Raoul was mentioned, she looked down, away from the others, in complete shock and disbelief. And when Meg volunteered Christine for Carlotta’s place, I actually thought Harriet/Christine might start crying. She looked so distressed and uncomfortable. I love how shakily she starts out singing, like she really, really doesn’t want to be there. But watching the sheer joy overwhelm her as she realizes that she can sing is just beautiful to watch. Joyful is always the word I use to describe Harriet’s TOM, but there was something extra special about it tonight (and thus, my tears began, and never stopped).

Harriet Jones (Her Twitter)

In Angel of Music, Harriet and Daisy were very cute together; I loved how giggly they were with each other, and Christine really seemed to want to confide in Meg, but just couldn’t, and Meg could sense this. It was a really nice little scene. I’m honestly not sure how to accurately describe what Harriet’s acting was like in the AOM with Raoul bit, but it was very effective. She clearly remembered him well, and loved him from the get-go, but maintained her cautious distance so as not to anger her ‘angel’. When she mentioned this ‘angel’, she became instantly uneasy; her entire body language changed. I think what I really loved was how scared Harriet’s Christine was of the Phantom, essentially through the whole show. She was outright terrified of him, even before she went to the lair. And with Ben’s downright lunatic Phantom, it worked. So that any mention of this angel made her uncomfortable was a nice touch, and I loved the consistency. She was definitely never in love with the Phantom.

Great acting in title song boat ride; loved the sense of wonder and astonishment, but also fear and confusion rather than just halfheartedly looking around. She had no idea what she was walking (well, riding) into (and clearly wasn’t sure if she really wanted to be there), and that showed in her face and body language. Music of the Night was another good one for Harriet; she didn’t seem to go totally into a trance, but was looking around and exploring and trying to figure out what the heck was happening. Especially when the Phantom was feeling up her hair. The look on Harriet’s face was priceless.

Rest of first act was great, Harriet’s very cheeky and sly as Serafimo. She’s very ‘old school’ in a way; less static and bland than recent Christines have been in this scene. She was the last Christine to be an entertaining Serafimo, so I’m glad she’s held onto that. I really enjoyed the moment when Raoul was trying to tell Christine that there was no Phantom, she looked absolutely disgusted with him, recoiled while shoving him away, and practically spat, “Raoul, I’ve been there!” She was furious with him, and I think it makes AIAOY make more sense – he needs to regain her trust, she needs him to promise to protect and love her. And I love, love, LOVE what Harriet does when Raoul kneels for what I call “the proposal” bit of the song; she watches him in shock for a moment, then kneels down to be level to him for the rest of the phrase, before pulling him up. It’s such a nice touch, and a really beautiful moment between the two characters.

Act two! Otherwise known as the emotional thunderstorm of feels. Yes, that’s its official name.

Harriet Jones (Tumblr)

Harriet’s always lovely in Masquerade. She’s the only one with the complexion and wig colour to pull off the ‘Retina Burner’ dress. It might have helped her if she spotted the chaine turns in the dancing bit, she looked a bit dizzy after them. Loved how attached she was to Raoul and how focused her attention was on him. I don’t love the weird new choreography (“To the left! Take it back now y’all!” was literally all I could think of during it), but Harriet’s very elegant, so she made it look good, something a number of the actors (i.e. non-dancers) didn’t seem quite able to do.

Notes II was really good; loved Harriet’s ferocity here. She was so completely fed up with the way everyone was treating her and walking all over her. It was great to see her get in Carlotta’s face and release some of that frustration. Her “How dare you!” was piercing. From that point, Harriet’s Christine got more and more hysterical, until she was a sobbing mess, running off the stage in a flurry of skirts, with a barely intelligible, “I can’t!” And when she comes into the rehearsal scene, she looks incredibly uncomfortable, as if she’s being forced rather than showed up of her own free will. It makes you wonder what happened between those two scenes. Also, Harriet has these huge eyes that, when the light hits them just right, look absolutely haunting – like they’re staring into your soul. When the piano started playing on its own, she looked out into the audience with those terrifying eyes, and you just sensed the utter horror in Christine’s mind. And that was how the end of the rehearsal and start of Wishing made me cry like an infant.

I’d always considered Wishing to be Harriet’s weakness – yeah, not so much after today. I don’t think this girl has a weakness anymore. Her ‘Wishing’ was so beautifully acted – heartrending and raw without being overdone or feeling too act-y (and she’s axed the fake crying). You can feel the passion in her voice so much more than a year ago. It was a truly beautiful, yet heartbreaking, thing to witness. But I liked the sheer amount of growth Harriet put across in just one song; she went from scared child, to confident grown woman in three minutes. I also loved her strut away at the end, fists clenched, head held high. It’s so different from Lisa’s defeated demeanor at the end of the song. Harriet’s Christine has gained confidence and resolve, and has finished the song a stronger person than when she started. Yet the Phantom can so easily break in and invade her consciousness once again. It really gives you an idea of the power he has over Christine. Now, what was really interesting was when the Phantom waltzed back in and took over her mind again, Harriet went very happy. As in, all smiles and bounciness. I liked it, but I didn’t understand it. I’d love to hear Harriet’s take on that moment, and why she chose to play it that way, but my guess is it’s part of the ‘hypnotic’ state the Phantom keeps Christine in, and rather than going robot, she goes happy? I’m not sure really. Liked it, but didn’t get it.

Harriet Jones (Tumblr)

PONR was great, as usual. Harriet really fought Ben (like, really, really. I though he might snap her wrist), and I love her attention to detail and how spontaneous she can make everything feel. It was like watching a fresh show; I knew what was going to happen, but she kept surprising me with the when. I loved it. But the new apron on her costume is awful. I love that even though the Phantom had such a tight grip on her, she positively wrenched her arms away with so much force that I think it shocked him a bit. I think what worried the Phantom in this scene is that he didn’t expect Christine to fight back. It was interesting because, for a second, they swapped roles. Christine was in control, and the Phantom was the one scared and confused. The pattern is too big, the shape is wrong, and it doesn’t move with the rest of the dress the way the fringed apron does. Bad move, costume department. I also don’t really like when Christine’s manhandle the skirt; just let it swish! It’s so pretty that way.

The Final Lair was… wow. I couldn’t see a lot of it through my tears (all Harriet’s fault), but what I saw was quite something. In general, Harriet’s levelheadedness (that sounds a bit odd, but everything Christine says and does in that scene seems very logical, so Christine always comes off as levelheaded, even when she’s hysterical) was a good contrast to Ben’s schizophrenic Phantom. Actually the two of them were a nice balance throughout. Neither over or underwhelmed the other. Harriet was absolutely ferocious, she LEPT in between the Phantom and Raoul; even after being manhandled by the Phantom, she wasn’t deterred from defending herself and Raoul. She literally spit out “tears of hate” and, “you deceived me;” it was a flurry of sheer anger and fire. At the very, very end, when she was giving the ring back, the Phantom didn’t want to take it. But she held his hand, opened it, placed the ring in it, and closed his hand with both of hers. It was a small moment of genuine compassion that the Phantom desperately needed.

Harriet Jones (Tumblr)

If I could summarise Harriet’s portrayal of Christine briefly, there’s an overall sense of her having been thrown into a situation she doesn’t like and doesn’t think is fair. It’s a very headstrong portrayal; Christine is clearly her own person, and isn’t willing to bend to the instructions of others unless absolutely necessary. I think that’s why she demonstrated having such a hard time letting go of her father, and why she was so angry at and afraid of the Phantom. For her, the kiss at the end of the final lair was the ultimate sacrifice, because she didn’t want to do it. It took a lot for her to let go of that control she so badly craved. She didn’t love the Phantom, and that was clear from the beginning. But she put Raoul before herself, and I think that showed a tremendous amount of growth and maturity in her portrayal. It was a simple concept, that required very thoughtful, detailed acting to pull off, and Harriet did an absolutely exquisite job. Brava!

On a non-acting note, I don’t think I really appreciated before how natural Harriet’s voice is. In my head, I always think of her as having this huge, spectacular voice, and she does, but when she sings, it doesn’t seem like she’s forcing it. I’m not sure if that makes sense, but it’s as if she was just born to sing Christine’s part. It really does make a big difference; you don’t get distracted watching her try to push the notes out or try to be really showy with her voice. She just sings it, and you can sit back and appreciate the rest of her portrayal, complemented by her gorgeous, effortless voice. I also love how distinct her voice is; it’s not just your standard soprano la-di-da, and she has her own unique tone and sound without sounding too weird (a la Sierra Boggess and her bizarre vowels). You can tell it’s her, without actually having to see her. Anyway, Harriet’s voice is perfection, and we all know that.  

I have to say, I was a bit surprised to see Harriet back so quickly (I was hoping she might go do Glinda or Johanna, then come back to Phantom), but I was so, so thrilled with her performance. She was, essentially, flawless. And so, so natural. I thought back to the first time I saw her, November 2^nd 2013 (nearly three years ago), when she was this small, ridiculously pretty Christine with the big voice and oodles of potential. Watching her entire journey as Christine, and seeing how she developed and changed as a performer, has been an absolute joy, and I am so excited to continue watching her in the year ahead (I really, really hope she’s staying all year!). Here’s to seeing Harriet’s Christine another 25.5 times!

Ben Forster (Phantom Website)

Ben Forster’s Phantom is certainly something. As I tweeted, it’s the weirdest thing I’ve ever seen on a stage. You’re either going to love it or hate it; I was very unsure the first time I saw him, but this time I absolutely loved what he’d done with the part. It was so unique; Ben’s portrayal is the only time I’ve seen a Phantom that was completely and utterly psychotic. He had no humanity or rationality; there was no ‘misunderstood exile who just wants to be loved,’ the Phantom clearly blames his solitary living on his deformity, but in reality it’s probably because he’s a complete psychopath. Ben described it as a schizophrenic, and he absolutely hit the nail on the head with that description. The other words I would’ve used are creepy and disturbed. 

Just a few notable things that I’d like to mention; Ben’s music of the night is downright terrifying. He’s in Harriet’s face, feeling her up, twitching and smiling off into the distance – at one point he caught my eye, saw me looking horrified, and gave this malicious smile. Thanks for the nightmares, Ben. It was as if he’d waited for this moment for so long, and he was just all over Christine. But it wasn’t sexual; it was more possessive, convincing himself that she was his. Then when you get to PONR, their next direct interaction of any length (Masquerade barely counts), it’s driving him crazy that he can’t hold onto her in that way. His hands are constantly twitching and grasping at other things. And even in the mirror during Angel of Music, when Christine starts singing to him, Ben smiles darkly like he’s saying, “Yes. She’s mine.” Something else I noticed the first time I saw him last March is that he has a very snake like quality, in that he never really stops moving, as well as investigating his surroundings looking for threats. This is most evident in Stranger Than You Dreamt It, when Ben positively slithers across the floor towards Christine. It’s like watching a cobra waiting to strike. Beautiful yet terrifying.

There’s not a whole lot else for me to write about, but that doesn’t mean I didn’t like him. I did, it’s just that I liked the portrayal as a whole rather than any particulars. And as others have said, Ben doesn’t have the strongest voice. The notes aren’t as pure or as clear as one might expect (especially during MOTN and anything that began with an I), but I think Ben really manages to work with that. He goes for a raspier, sharper tone that is completely in line with the rest of his unhinged portrayal (that said, his belt on, “It’s over now, the music of the night!” is scarily impressive). Ben made his deficiencies work, and I commend him for that. It’s a tricky thing to do. Moreover, he clearly puts every ounce of energy he has into maintaining the consistency of his character, which has to be absolutely exhausting given how frenetic his Phantom is, both in body and mind.

Ben has definitely become an unexpected favourite of mine, and I certainly look forward to seeing him in the role again. He’s really made the role his own, and clearly spent a lot of time creating a unique take on the Phantom that others would’ve found too risky.

Nadim Naaman (Tumblr)

I’ve already written about Nadim extensively, but something small that I like that he’s now doing is when the Christines say, “You’ll guard me and you’ll guide me?” in All I Ask of You, he nods and says, “Yes!” or “Of course!” It’s adorable. I also love him and Harriet together; they play off of each other wonderfully. As well, I loved that when Nadim was pushing the boat out of the lair, and Ben was looking longingly through the gate, the two made eye contact for a moment, before Nadim turned back to Christine. I would love to know what was going on in each of their heads at that moment; it was a small but really cool detail. I think it’s either Raoul’s promise to look after Christine, or a somewhat possessive, “She’s mine now.” Christine doesn’t see any of this; I think it’s particularly poignant that she never looks back at the Phantom.

Grace Horne
(Tumblr)

Wasn’t a fan of Paul Morrissey’s Piangi; it was boring and uninspiring. I honestly barely noticed him in the show. He just wasn’t reacting to anything. Jacinta was great as Mme Giry, as was Megan as Carlotta (nothing new there). Phillip Griffiths as Andre was alright. He seemed a bit tired; Andre is usually quite energetic, providing a foil to Firmin. I missed that in his performance. Sion Lloyd was ok as Firmin; I expected a bit more from him in terms of characterization given his performance in Titanic, but maybe it’ll come with time. Daisy Hulbert has improved significantly. Her singing voice isn’t strong, but at least she’s in tune most of the time now. I found her face in Hannibal distracting; she was making this scrunched up, “I’ve smelt something bad” face that made absolutely no sense. Her acting, though often very over the top, has improved. She and Harriet are very cute in the Dressing Room scene; the handholding and giggling is really adorable. They truly seemed like close friends, and I loved that Daisy’s Meg showed genuine concern for Christine’s wellbeing. Not the worst Meg every, but certainly on the overly perky side.

Lori Gilchrist
(Phantom Website)

On the Ballet Girl front, I am still loving Grace Horne (she’s only getting better and better). Her acting has really gotten good; the part in Il Muto where she has to fall out of a pirouette and gasp because she’s seen the Phantom’s shadow is flawlessly executed. I don’t know what her singing voice sounds like, but I’d love to see her have a go at Meg in the future. And I really loved one of the new BGs, Lori Gilchrist. You can tell she’s incredibly experienced (check out her bio on the Phantom website; she's literally done everything); her arms are absolutely divine and she is so ridiculously elegant. I would love her not to make the scared/worried face the whole show, but that’ll come with time. She’s just a gorgeous dancer with stunning technique; it’s a shame she’s the monkey as I think her talents would be better suited to the butterfly or triton, but she makes the most of it with beautiful extensions and uses the opportunity to show off her crisp technique. The other new BG, Morven Douglas is alright. She looks a lot like Danielle actually, and is even thinner than Danielle. I was too busy watching Lori and Grace to really get a good look at her though.

So… that’s that! It was such an incredible performance and I enjoyed every second of it (even when I was bawling!). Harriet is flawless, Ben is so different and exciting – it’s just a great cast right now. I cannot wait to return! (And shout out to the new conductor who nearly hit me with a baton – hazards of the front row! Loved his enthusiasm for the piece though, it was such fun to watch).

The wonderful cast of Phantom!