The Phantom of the Opera
This is another composite review of two shows; it was an identical
cast for both, but obviously there were some different things that happened
differently in either show, so where applicable I’ll note that. I've organised it by scenes; so if something has an arrow, that just means the first scene through to the end of the second scene listed.
Auction à Think of Me
Raoul’s "Boy" is very loud – he doesn’t sound like a weak old man,
though it fits with the rest of the portrayal. Hannibal was pretty normal; they were short a few dancers so they
looked a bit sparse, but not a big issue (the BGs were also very blonde today).
The ensemble is missing most of the little details that the last cast put in. Fiona Finsbury as Carlotta has improved quite a bit. She’s much
less shrill and bug-eyed (makeup fix or she’s just stopped opening her eyes so
wide; whatever she’s done, it’s great). The accent is much more accurate and
consistent now. I still miss a bit of personality (there’s no consistent
trait/traits that carry through her performance). Anyway, Hannibal and her bit
of Think of Me was well sung and well acted. What I most love about Layla’s
Meg is that she’s not the Phantom’s resident (and very annoying) announcer. She
makes Meg a real and important character who has a huge (and very
unappreciated) part in the show. That said, she does do the Phantom’s
announcements very nicely (volume, conviction; nothing much to say aside from
it’s just the way I like it). LOVE watching her and Reyer. She’s cheekily
peeking over at the score, and makes the most proud face when Christine starts
being a good singer. It’s really cute. Emmi’s definitely worked on her accent; it’s much less apparent
now. It mostly pops up when she has small spoken bits (or any phrases that need
to be sung/spoken very quickly; i.e. “we must go to the roof, we’ll be safe
there!” It also tends to come out when she’s saying something with a W in it.
No idea why, but she’s not dropping the ends off of words now, so yay!) The
weird thing she does in Think of Me is on the cadenza and the vibrato (I think
that’s what it’s called?) at the end, she ‘jiggles’, for lack of a better turn.
As in, her shoulders and arms wiggle up and down. It is very bizarre and not
particularly attractive. Think of Me was great until that (well, she did get
her scarf caught in her face, but that was pretty funny and she handled it well
– I have massive respect for performers that are able to shake off something
like that – in this case, literally!).
Angel of Music
Layla and Emmi are absolutely adorable together. Their Meg and
Christine gel really well; their mannerisms match each other and they really do
seem like best friends. I like that because so often Meg just gets ignored, and
I don’t think she should be, so having the “BFF” aspect of Christine and Meg be
very apparent is great. Layla’s got a beautiful voice; clear, pure, and really
nice volume this time. And the face she makes when Mme Giry is annoyed at her.
I died. I honestly didn’t watch the Raoul/Christine part of Angel of
Music. The ballet was too enticing.
Phantom of the Opera/Music of the Night/Stranger Than You Dreamt It
Nothing special about the Title Song; it was good enough. Emmi
missed the big ‘swish’ to the audience near the end (when the Phantom sort of
‘throws’ his arms outwards), but it looked ok. Both do the lip synch very well. Music of the Night was beautiful performed by Scott. Emmi was
fairly uninteresting (honestly I remember nothing that she did during MOTN,
which means she did nothing that wowed me but nothing bad either). But WOW that STYDI! Loved it. Fabulous acting from both Emmi and
Scott. Bit of an awkward mask hand-back, but still, the acting was great! And
the Mirror Bride kept still this time, so good for her.
Buquet à Prima Donna
I loved this Buquet (no
idea who it was though). He was a lot less outwardly creepy, but there was just
something very dark, yet almost comical, about him. I don’t really know how to
describe it, but it worked very well. I loved when he jabbed his finger at Meg,
then sort of drew it around at two of the other girls. Also his reaction to Mme
Giry was pretty funny. But oh my goodness, Notes through Prima Donna is the Layla
Harrison show. I know Meg’s not technically supposed to be the focus of those
scenes, (Hi, Carlotta) but you can’t not watch
her (aside from Layla’s generally magnetic stage presence). She just does the
most brilliant facial expressions in reaction to Carlotta’s diva tantrum at the
end of Notes and the beginning of Prima Donna. I’d love to know what’s going on
in Meg’s head at that point, because it’s probably pretty funny. But that
changes to sincere concern for Christine; she’s obviously trying to figure
something out, but everyone just sort of pushes Meg away. Layla expresses this
beautifully; it’s just so real. You don’t hear too much from Meg in this scene
(though with Layla you can actually hear something!), but what you do is beautifully
sung. I can’t really say too much about anyone else in that scene, but nothing
disastrous or outstanding happened (you know, aside from Layla-Meg being
incredible).
Il Muto à Chandelier Crash
This was certainly Emmi’s weakest scene. There was just nothing
coming from her. Nothing. It was like she’d accidentally found herself on stage
and was trying really hard to blend into the background. Not too impressed with
that. I don’t mind people not going for the really out there Serafimo (a la
Olivia Brereton or Samantha Hill), but if you’re going to play shy/quiet
Serafimo, sell it. Don’t just stand
there and look blank. Everyone else was good; I loved watching Layla (again, the faces!!
So perfect and funny. Also I love her costume for Il Muto; the dress is a
gorgeous colour and the style suits her perfectly. And those shoes are my
favourite costume piece in the show). Fiona was good in this scene; not as
pissed off as I usually like Carlotta to be, but she did the croaking and panic
very convincingly. I love Tim Laurenti as Andre’s introduction to the Ballet.
The audience, myself included, were in hysterics.
Excuse the most unprofessional sentence I will ever publish, but ASFHASJGSG Layla danced the featured part in
Il Muto! And she was beautiful at it; she’s just such a gorgeous dancer to
watch. The movements were all fluid yet precise at the same time, and the
expressions is just WOW. Can she
dance that part every time? Please?
All I Ask of You was fine. Not hugely emotional but better than
last time. Liam and Emmi are still doing the face smush kiss (that’s a literal
description of it). Because I’m a ten year old (*insert eye roll*) I usually
cover my eyes for the kiss, but I’d rather sit through Olivia and Antony’s
ultra passionate kiss than the face smush. It’s just not romantic at all.
That’s one thing, I didn’t get a lot of connection between Christine and Raoul
in this show. I mean, they were fine, but there was no overwhelming sense of
love; nothing that made you think they were meant to be together, no matter
what happened. I feel like Christine would’ve dumped Raoul shortly after the
show ended. I never like how Christine’s pulled off when the Chandelier goes
down. What the heck is Raoul doing on stage?! And why doesn’t Christine just
run? (I have a theory that Christine is just really, really stupid). Anyway, it
was fine. Everyone looked suitably terrified.
I LOVE this scene so much; the bursts of colour, the gorgeous
dancing, the sparkly costumes… it’s beautiful. Also for other reasons that’re
unrelated to the show itself but nonetheless make the scene one of my
favourites. Of course made better by my favourite Meg just being generally perfect.
No major things to note, but I do love how everyone freezes during “Christine,
Christine!” and then all hell breaks lose. It’s a nice piece of choreography.
Poor Layla had to do the kick in the corner on her own (usually there’s two
dancers supporting each other), which looks... hazardous. Also, I seriously
love Georgia’s Butterfly Costume. The bodice (purple with a black lace overlay)
is stunning and the skirt is just so darn sparkly. A note on Emmi’s Retina Burner (aka her Star Princess dress). It’s
not so bad on stage. Still obnoxiously fluorescent, but the colours relax under
the stage lights. The skirt is beautiful actually; the combination of blue,
white and pink is lovely when it twirls. It’s the bodice that just thoroughly
ugly (and brighter too; the bodice and skirt aren’t the same colour). Still a
hideous version of the costume (can the costume dept please bring back the
beautiful pale dresses?), but not as bad as it looks in photos.
Notes II à Rehearsal
Notes II was very uninteresting. Not bad, just nothing special. I
liked Liam’s “You don’t have to, they can’t make you!” The way Raoul interacts
with Christine, it seems as though he thinks of her more as a business rather
than someone he’s in love with. Liam plays this angle well, though I don’t like
to see Raoul played that way. The rehearsal for Don Juan was another Layla-Meg scene; she’s just
so much fun to watch. There’s never a dull moment; I could spend ages writing
about all the little details and the cute/funny things she did. Super Meg! Also,
Emmi and Layla have an adorable connection as Christine and Meg; they gel very
well, so the friendship between the two characters seems very real and strong,
which I love. Layla’s Meg is very attentive to Christine, and Emmi’s Christine
responds nicely to Meg as opposed to ignoring her.
Wishing à Wandering Child
Emmi’s cloak fell off in the first show. As in, the backpack
straps and clips in her hair were the only things holding it on her body.
Again, well handled; she didn’t fuss with it (I do prefer when they fix things
like this rather than just ignoring them, but I can’t fault just ignoring it;
there’s nothing wrong with it, just personal preference). But Emmi’s ‘Wishing’
is nice enough. Nothing extraordinary, but there’s nothing to fault (except her
basically blowing her nose in her scarf at the beginning…). Wandering Child was nice; Emmi does a really
good ‘hypnotized’ face. Convincing, not overdone. Ignored Raoul.
PONR
I think PONR is probably Emmi’s favourite song; is where we get
the most personality from her. I think what her Christine lacks is development;
she just speaks the lines or sings the song, there’s no motivation or carrying
character traits behind it. I like the way that Emmi and Scott do everything on
the bench, and him dragging her around after she realizes who he is. One thing
that did make me giggle was when she ripped his mask and wig off. Blank face.
Arms went up. Arms came down with a mask and hair in them. Finito. It was just
so… lackluster? Unexpected? Either way, it was strange.
Final Lair
Holy bananas, Scott went a little beserk here, especially the
second show! On the boat ride his hands were shaking and spasming – it was
legitimately terrifying. It looked as if he was having a psychological break or
something. Brilliant, but terrifying. I liked him a lot better than I have in
the past; really big and dramatic, but not as overdone (though that might’ve
been because he was beside Emmi’s stoic Christine and Liam’s forgettable
Raoul). Liam’s “Christine! Christine!” when she was kissing the Phantom was very
well done; I liked that addition. Emmi gets quite fiery in the final lair… but
her face doesn’t do a whole lot. Stoic really is the best word for it. And finally, the reveal of the Phantom’s mask at the very end of
the show. Layla managed the most elegant cape sweep I’ve ever seen (she did it
such that she got both the cape and the wedding veil out of her way so she
wasn’t kneeling on them. Very impressive). What better way to end the show that
with one final look at the most well-rounded, expressive, generally perfect
Meg.